Photometric Plans for Site Plan Approval in Ontario: What Municipalities Ask For and How to Pass Review
Most Ontario municipalities will not approve a site plan for a commercial, institutional or multi-residential project until an exterior lighting plan and a photometric plot have been reviewed. The request is usually one line in the site plan comments, but it carries hard numbers: zero lux at the property line, full cut-off fixtures, a maximum colour temperature and, in some cities, a sealed certification. This guide explains what GTA municipalities ask for, where they differ, and how a photometric plan is produced so that it passes the first review.
Why Municipalities Ask for a Photometric Plan
Site plan control under the Planning Act lets a municipality regulate exterior lighting as part of the site design. Guelph's lighting guideline, for example, cites section 41(7)(a)(5) of the Act and applies to commercial, industrial, institutional, recreational and multi-residential developments of three or more units. Barrie and Grimsby list the illumination study as a supporting document for site plan control; Oakville asks for a lighting plan under site plan control and a photometric plot where a development is next to sensitive land uses; Richmond Hill reviews site lighting under its site alteration permit process.
The concern is the same everywhere: light trespass onto neighbouring lots, glare, sky glow and, in Toronto, the effect on migratory birds. The photometric plot is the one document that proves, in numbers, that light stays on the site. It is a planning deliverable, reviewed before the building permit by planners and sometimes by a peer-review engineer at the applicant's cost (Barrie says so explicitly), so a complete submission moves faster.
Who Prepares and Seals It
The wording varies by municipality, and the difference matters for who you hire.
- Barrie: an engineer qualified in exterior, roadway and parking lot lighting; all reports and drawings stamped, signed and dated by a qualified professional licensed in Ontario.
- Guelph: the submission is stamped by the Professional Engineer responsible for the plan.
- Oakville: the lighting plan may be prepared by a professional engineer, a full member of the Canadian Institute of Planners, a registered architect or a registered landscape architect, in consultation with a professional electrical engineer qualified in exterior lighting; the photometric plot itself must be prepared by a professional engineer qualified in exterior lighting.
- Richmond Hill: a certification statement on the drawings that the lighting complies with By-law 63-95, signed and sealed with a current date.
- Grimsby: the study should be completed by a qualified professional engineer, registered architect or registered landscape architect with experience in exterior lighting plans.
In practice the architect or landscape architect often carries the lighting plan on their drawings, and the electrical engineer produces the photometric plot and the fixture selection behind it. Where a seal is required, an engineer licensed by Professional Engineers Ontario provides it; our guide on when a P.Eng. stamp is required in Ontario covers the general rules.
What the Submission Contains
Barrie, Oakville and Grimsby use nearly identical wording for the lighting plan: the location, height and type of all existing and proposed fixtures, with mounting height measured from adjacent grade to the underside of the fixture; the location of the electrical supply; the areas to be illuminated, checked against existing and proposed vegetation; a notation that fixtures are full cut-off and dark-sky compliant; and manufacturer data with photometric data and the IESNA full cut-off designation. The photometric plot then shows the calculated illuminance in lux across the site, extended 6.0 m beyond the property lines.
Richmond Hill and Guelph read like an engineering specification: a point-by-point plot of maintained horizontal illuminance with a statistics table (average, maximum, minimum, ratios); a luminaire schedule (manufacturer, catalogue number, wattage, source, mounting height); cut sheets with BUG ratings or flux tables (Richmond Hill); pole specifications and isolux curves (Guelph); the software used, with a grid laid out per IES RP-8 and RP-20 (Guelph names AGi32 as an example); a post-installation sign-off (Guelph) and a cost estimate (Richmond Hill). Even where a municipality's list is short, the fuller package answers the reviewer's questions before they are asked.
The Numbers Reviewers Check
1. Light at the property line
Barrie, Oakville and Grimsby all require 0.0 lux at all property lines, with readings shown to 6.0 m beyond the line. Guelph sets the limit by lighting zone: 0 lux at the limit of the Natural Heritage System (LZ1), 2 lux in LZ2, 5 lux in LZ3 and 7.5 lux in LZ4, with the more restrictive value applying where zones meet. Toronto's Best Practices for Effective Lighting asks that combined light not raise the illuminance at the property line by more than about 1 lux. Richmond Hill requires the maximum and minimum values at the property perimeter to be reported. Zero lux is met with full cut-off optics, house-side shields where a pole sits near the line, and a calculation grid that proves it rather than a note that claims it.
2. Light on the site
- Toronto cites Municipal Code section 629-36 for a minimum of 10 lux (0.9 foot-candles) in parking lots, walkways and similar areas, and names a 3:1 uniformity ratio as typical best practice.
- Richmond Hill caps the site's overall average maintained horizontal illuminance at 16.14 lux (1.5 fc) until 11 pm and 10.76 lux (1.0 fc) from 11 pm to 5 am; the night-time value is shown by a second photometric analysis or a drawing note describing the timer or dimming control. Sign surfaces are limited to an average vertical illuminance of 64.6 lux (6 fc).
- Guelph gives parking and loading values for basic and enhanced security (minimum 20 and 50 lux, uniformity 20:1 and 15:1, average vertical 10 and 25 lux) and private road values (6.0 lux average with a 2.0 lux minimum on commercial and industrial sites, 4.5 and 1.5 lux on residential and institutional sites). Car dealerships and service stations have their own tables.
Toronto and Guelph set minimums for safety; Richmond Hill sets a maximum against over-lighting. A design that satisfies both is the goal everywhere.
3. Fixture optics and colour
- Full cut-off. Barrie, Oakville, Grimsby and Guelph require it; Toronto defines it as zero light above the horizontal and less than 10 per cent at 10 degrees below the horizontal. Toronto's Green Standard requires exterior fixtures to be dark-sky compliant: a Dark Sky Seal, or full cut-off at 3000 K or less.
- Colour temperature. Guelph specifies 3000 K LED. Richmond Hill allows 4000 K or less with a stated preference for 3000 K. Toronto's best practice is a maximum of 3000 K in residential and mixed-use areas and 4000 K along high-traffic arterials.
- Glare and uplight. Guelph limits glare to IES TM-15 ratings G0 to G1 (G1 for parking lots, G0 for private roads and driveways). Richmond Hill limits uplight to less than 2 per cent. Where BUG ratings are requested, the cut sheet must show them.
4. Pole height and curfews
Guelph limits poles to 4.5 m in LZ1 and LZ2 and 6.0 m in LZ3 and LZ4, with 7.3 m allowed on industrial or large commercial sites of 2,000 m² or more. Richmond Hill's 11 pm reduction is a curfew in all but name, and Toronto's Green Standard requires façade lighting to be extinguished from 10 pm to 6 am. Where a curfew applies, the package needs a second calculation at the reduced level or a clear control note.
Reading a photometric plot at the property line
An illustrative site, not a photometric design: the grid values come from a simple model.
Detail A: full cut-off
Zero light above the horizontal; a house-side shield near the line
Parts
Property line: 0.0 lux at all property lines in Barrie, Oakville and Grimsby; Guelph sets the limit by lighting zone. Barrie · Oakville · Grimsby
The band beyond the line: readings shown to 6.0 m beyond the property line.
Point-by-point grid: maintained horizontal illuminance in lux, with a statistics table (average, maximum, minimum, ratios). Richmond Hill · Guelph
Isolux contours: contours alone, with no point values and no statistics table, cannot be checked.
Poles P1–P4: location, height and type of every fixture, with mounting height measured from adjacent grade to the underside of the fixture.
House-side shields: where a pole sits near the line, with full cut-off optics and a calculation grid that proves zero lux.
Full cut-off, as Toronto defines it: zero light above the horizontal and less than 10 per cent at 10 degrees below the horizontal. City of Toronto, Best Practices for Effective Lighting
- Property line
- Isolux contour
- 6.0 m beyond the line
City-by-City Differences in the GTA
The table summarizes what each document states. "Not stated" means the published terms give no value; the reviewer may still apply IES recommended practice.
| Municipality | Who signs | Property line | On-site levels | Colour and optics | Trigger |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toronto | Not stated | About +1 lux (best practice) | Min. 10 lux parking and walkways (Code 629-36); 3:1 uniformity typical | Max. 3000 K residential, 4000 K arterials; dark-sky compliant (TGS) | TGS v4 applies to new planning applications (applied through interim checklists since Bill 98) |
| Barrie | Qualified engineer; stamped, signed, dated | 0.0 lux; show 6.0 m beyond | Not stated | Full cut-off, dark-sky | Site plan control; CPPS |
| Oakville | Lighting plan: P.Eng., MCIP, architect or landscape architect; photometric plot: P.Eng. qualified in exterior lighting | 0.0 lux; show 6.0 m beyond | Not stated | Full cut-off | Site plan control; plot where adjacent to sensitive uses |
| Richmond Hill | Certification to By-law 63-95; signed and sealed | Max. and min. reported | Site average max. 16.14 lux to 11 pm, 10.76 lux after | 4000 K or less (3000 K preferred); uplight under 2%; BUG data | Site alteration permit |
| Guelph | Stamped by the responsible P.Eng. | 0 / 2 / 5 / 7.5 lux by lighting zone | Parking min. 20 or 50 lux; 20:1 or 15:1; roads 6.0/2.0 lux | 3000 K; full cut-off, IDA compliant; glare G0–G1 | Site plan approval, 3+ unit residential and non-residential |
| Grimsby | P.Eng., architect or landscape architect (should) | 0.0 lux; show 6.0 m beyond | Not stated | Full cut-off | Site plan control (OP 9.12.3) |
For Mississauga, Vaughan, Markham and Brampton we did not find a standalone lighting terms of reference; their expectations sit in the site plan application checklist and the urban design guidelines. Confirm the current checklist with the planner on the file before the plot is produced. Our service area pages list the planning and permit offices for each municipality.
How the Plan Is Produced
A photometric plot is a calculation, not a drawing exercise. The sequence we follow:
- Collect the inputs: site and grading plans, the landscape plan (tree canopies block light), elevations where wall-mounted or façade fixtures are proposed, and the municipal terms of reference.
- Set the targets: the municipal limits, the IES recommended practice for the use (RP-20 for parking, RP-8 for roadways and walkways) and the client's security needs.
- Select fixtures: full cut-off LED luminaires at the required colour temperature, with IES photometric files; BUG rating, distribution type (II to V) and house-side shields drive the choice near property lines.
- Model the site in AGi32 or Visual, with obstructions, a calculation grid at the IES spacing and a maintained light loss factor, so the values represent the installation after lamp depreciation and dirt, not the first night.
- Iterate pole positions, heights and optics until the property line reads zero, the on-site minimum and uniformity are met, and the pole count is as low as it can be.
- Produce the package: the plot with isolux contours and point values, the statistics table, the luminaire schedule, cut sheets with BUG data, pole and base details, the control note (timer, dimming, curfew) and the seal or certification the municipality requires.
The electrical side follows: branch circuits under the Canadian Electrical Code, with voltage drop checked on the long runs site lighting always has (see our voltage drop guide), photocell or astronomical time-clock control, and an ESA notification. Where EV chargers share the parking lot, the same site electrical design covers both; see our EVEMS guide.
Common Reasons for Rejection
- Light over the line. A plot showing 0.3 lux at a residential boundary where 0.0 is required. Fix: house-side shields, a lower mounting height, a tighter optic or a shifted pole.
- No grid. Contours alone, with no point values and no statistics table, cannot be checked.
- Missing cut sheets or BUG data. Full cut-off cannot be confirmed from a catalogue number.
- Wrong colour temperature. A 5000 K fixture on a 3000 K site; confirm the CCT on the cut sheet, not just the model family.
- Initial values instead of maintained, or trees ignored. A plot without a light loss factor overstates performance; a canopy modelled as open ground produces dark spots once the landscape matures.
- No curfew demonstration, or no seal where the terms of reference call for one.
What to Send Your Engineer
A photometric plan can usually be turned around quickly once the inputs are complete. To start, send the site plan and grading plan in CAD with property lines and adjacent land uses identified; the landscape plan and building elevations; the municipality's terms of reference, checklist or the planner's comment letter; any fixture or pole standard the owner wants to keep; and the hours of operation and any security requirement for the parking area.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every site plan application need a photometric plan?
No. It is typically required for commercial, industrial, institutional and multi-residential developments, in some municipalities only where the site adjoins sensitive land uses. Check the site plan checklist or ask the planner on the file.
Who can seal a photometric plan in Ontario?
A professional engineer licensed by Professional Engineers Ontario. Some municipalities accept a lighting plan by an architect or landscape architect but still require the photometric plot from an engineer qualified in exterior lighting.
What does "0.0 lux at the property line" mean in practice?
The calculated maintained illuminance at every point along the property line must round to zero, and the plot must show values to 6.0 m beyond the line. It is achieved with full cut-off optics, careful pole placement and shields where needed.
What colour temperature should site lighting be?
Many GTA municipalities now specify or prefer 3000 K LED. Some allow up to 4000 K, usually with a preference for 3000 K, and Toronto allows 4000 K on high-traffic arterials. Confirm the current value before fixtures are specified.
Is a photometric plan the same as the electrical drawings?
No. The photometric plan is a planning submission that proves light levels. The electrical drawings for the building permit show the circuits, panels, controls and grounding that power the fixtures. The same engineer can produce both, which keeps the fixture selection consistent.
How long does a photometric plan take?
Once the site, grading and landscape plans and the municipal terms of reference are in hand, a typical commercial site is modelled and documented in a short time; tight property-line constraints take longer. Allow time for one round of municipal comments.
Sources
- City of Barrie, Terms of Reference: Illumination Study (2026).
- Town of Oakville, Development Application Guidelines: Lighting Plan and Photometric Plot Plan.
- City of Richmond Hill, Exterior Site Lighting Design Requirements and Light Pollution By-law 63-95.
- City of Guelph, Lighting Guidelines for Lighting Plans (May 2019).
- Town of Grimsby, Terms of Reference: Illumination Study (rev. December 2022).
- City of Toronto, Best Practices for Effective Lighting; Toronto Municipal Code Chapter 629; Toronto Green Standard.
- Illuminating Engineering Society, RP-8 (roadway and parking facility lighting), RP-20 (parking facilities), TM-15 (luminaire classification and BUG ratings).
- Canadian Electrical Code, Part I (CSA C22.1), Section 30; Ontario Electrical Safety Code.